When I saw this idea I knew immediately that I wanted to make them for my son's preschool and sunbeam teachers. So I went to the dollar store and picked up several 4x6 plastic frames. I cut the decorative paper out 4"x6". Put some scrapbook supplies to finish it off. Just in case you are wondering, the little flowers on the bottom left side are rub-ons directly on the plastic. Seriously, it was so easy and quick, each took about 5 minutes (if that).
I had my son (who is 4) write on the first post-it note to personalize it. I wanted my son to "make" the gifts, but I also wanted them to be cute so this was my easy solution, it was a win-win :)